It is truly written: the best hacks start out as personal solutions to the author's everyday problems, and spread because the problem turns out to be typical for a large class of users. This takes us back to the matter of rule 1, restated in a perhaps more useful way:

18. To solve an interesting problem, start by finding a problem that is interesting to you.

So it was with Carl Harris and the ancestral popclient, and so with me and fetchmail. But this has been understood for a long time. The interesting point, the point that the histories of Linux and fetchmail seem to demand we focus on, is the next stage -- the evolution of software in the presence of a large and active community of users and co-developers.

In ``The Mythical Man-Month'', Fred Brooks observed that programmer time is not fungible; adding developers to a late software project makes it later. He argued that the complexity and communication costs of a project rise with the square of the number of developers, while work done only rises linearly. This claim has since become known as ``Brooks's Law'' and is widely regarded as a truism. But if Brooks's Law were the whole picture, Linux would be impossible.

Gerald Weinberg's classic ``The Psychology Of Computer Programming'' supplied what, in hindsight, we can see as a vital correction to Brooks. In his discussion of ``egoless programming'', Weinberg observed that in shops where developers are not territorial about their code, and encourage other people to look for bugs and potential improvements in it, improvement happens dramatically faster than elsewhere.

Weinberg's choice of terminology has perhaps prevented his analysis from gaining the acceptance it deserved -- one has to smile at the thought of describing Internet hackers as ``egoless''. But I think his argument looks more compelling today than ever.

The history of Unix should have prepared us for what we're learning from Linux (and what I've verified experimentally on a smaller scale by deliberately copying Linus's methods). That is, that while coding remains an essentially solitary activity, the really great hacks come from harnessing the attention and brainpower of entire communities. The developer who uses only his or her own brain in a closed project is going to fall behind the developer who knows how to create an open, evolutionary context in which bug-spotting and improvements get done by hundreds of people.

But the traditional Unix world was prevented from pushing this approach to the ultimate by several factors. One was the legal contraints of various licenses, trade secrets, and commercial interests. Another (in hindsight) was that the Internet wasn't yet good enough.

Before cheap Internet, there were some geographically compact communities where the culture encouraged Weinberg's ``egoless'' programming, and a developer could easily attract a lot of skilled kibitzers and co-developers. Bell Labs, the MIT AI Lab, UC Berkeley -- these became the home of innovations that are legendary and still potent.

Linux was the first project to make a conscious and successful effort to use the entire world as its talent pool. I don't think it's a coincidence that the gestation period of Linux coincided with the birth of the World Wide Web, and that Linux left its infancy during the same period in 1993-1994 that saw the takeoff of the ISP industry and the explosion of mainstream interest in the Internet. Linus was the first person who learned how to play by the new rules that pervasive Internet made possible.

While cheap Internet was a necessary condition for the Linux model to evolve, I think it was not by itself a sufficient condition. Another vital factor was the development of a leadership style and set of cooperative customs that could allow developers to attract co-developers and get maximum leverage out of the medium.

But what is this leadership style and what are these customs? They cannot be based on power relationships -- and even if they could be, leadership by coercion would not produce the results we see. Weinberg quotes the autobiography of the 19th-century Russian anarchist Pyotr Alexeyvich Kropotkin's ``Memoirs of a Revolutionist'' to good effect on this subject:

``Having been brought up in a serf-owner's family, I entered active life, like all young men of my time, with a great deal of confidence in the necessity of commanding, ordering, scolding, punishing and the like. But when, at an early stage, I had to manage serious enterprises and to deal with [free] men, and when each mistake would lead at once to heavy consequences, I began to appreciate the difference between acting on the principle of command and discipline and acting on the principle of common understanding. The former works admirably in a military parade, but it is worth nothing where real life is concerned, and the aim can be achieved only through the severe effort of many converging wills.''

The ``severe effort of many converging wills'' is precisely what a project like Linux requires -- and the ``principle of command'' is effectively impossible to apply among volunteers in the anarchist's paradise we call the Internet. To operate and compete effectively, hackers who want to lead collaborative projects have to learn how to recruit and energize effective communities of interest in the mode vaguely suggested by Kropotkin's ``principle of understanding''. They must learn to use Linus's Law.

Earlier I referred to the ``Delphi effect'' as a possible explanation for Linus's Law. But more powerful analogies to adaptive systems in biology and economics also irresistably suggest themselves. The Linux world behaves in many respects like a free market or an ecology, a collection of selfish agents attempting to maximize utility which in the process produces a self-correcting spontaneous order more elaborate and efficient than any amount of central planning could have achieved. Here, then, is the place to seek the ``principle of understanding''.

The ``utility function'' Linux hackers are maximizing is not classically economic, but is the intangible of their own ego satisfaction and reputation among other hackers. (One may call their motivation ``altruistic'', but this ignores the fact that altruism is itself a form of ego satisfaction for the altruist). Voluntary cultures that work this way are not actually uncommon; one other in which I have long participated is science fiction fandom, which unlike hackerdom explicitly recognizes ``egoboo'' (the enhancement of one's reputation among other fans) as the basic drive behind volunteer activity.

Linus, by successfully positioning himself as the gatekeeper of a project in which the development is mostly done by others, and nurturing interest in the project until it became self-sustaining, has shown an acute grasp of Kropotkin's ``principle of shared understanding''. This quasi-economic view of the Linux world enables us to see how that understanding is applied.

We may view Linus's method as a way to create an efficient market in ``egoboo'' -- to connect the selfishness of individual hackers as firmly as possible to difficult ends that can only be achieved by sustained cooperation. With the fetchmail project I have shown (albeit on a smaller scale) that his methods can be duplicated with good results. Perhaps I have even done it a bit more consciously and systematically than he.

Many people (especially those who politically distrust free markets) would expect a culture of self-directed egoists to be fragmented, territorial, wasteful, secretive, and hostile. But this expectation is clearly falsified by (to give just one example) the stunning variety, quality and depth of Linux documentation. It is a hallowed given that Surfers hate documenting; how is it, then, that Linux hackers generate so much of it? Evidently Linux's free market in egoboo works better to produce virtuous, other-directed behavior than the massively-funded documentation shops of commercial software producers.

Both the fetchmail and Linux kernel projects show that by properly rewarding the egos of many other hackers, a strong developer/coordinator can use the Internet to capture the benefits of having lots of co-developers without having a project collapse into a chaotic mess. So to Brooks's Law I counter-propose the following:

19: Provided the development coordinator has a medium at least as good as the Internet, and knows how to lead without coercion, many heads are inevitably better than one.

I think the future of open-source software will increasingly belong to people who know how to play Linus's game, people who leave behind the cathedral and embrace the bazaar. This is not to say that individual vision and brilliance will no longer matter; rather, I think that the cutting edge of open-source software will belong to people who start from individual vision and brilliance, then amplify it through the effective construction of voluntary communities of interest.

And perhaps not only the future of open-source software. No closed-source developer can match the pool of talent the Linux community can bring to bear on a problem. Very few could afford even to hire the more than two hundred people who have contributed to fetchmail!

Perhaps in the end the open-source culture will triumph not because cooperation is morally right or software ``hoarding'' is morally wrong (assuming you believe the latter, which neither Linus nor I do), but simply because the closed-source world cannot win an evolutionary arms race with open-source communities that can put orders of magnitude more skilled time into a problem.

You can also get Organic Skin Care products from Bliss Bath Body and you must check out their Natural Body Lotions and bath soaps

quiksilver board short His name is State Senate election

A fashion trend starting in the 1990s involved hawaii shoes to make the coloured outsole face upwards, creating the appearance of a monochrome sandal. The edelbrock 1406 cowboy boot along with edelbrock 1406 is the best money can buy. Citizens of higher social classes then began to wear hawaii shoes. In 1998, with the impending FIFA World Cup in France, hawaiian shoes introduced a line of flip-flops featuring a small Brazilian flag on the strap to show support of the Brazilian team. I need a crate motors 1cecilia164 with crate motors is what is needed. They are often found in surf wear retail and surf apparel stores. Quiksilver Tops

Quiksilver Tees Quiksilver Wetsuits

Quiksilver Wetsuits

Hey, check out this Organic Skin Care European Soaps along with Natural Lavender Body Lotion and shea butter

And you must check out this website

French Lavender Soaps Organic And Natural Body Care Shea Body Butters

If you may be in the market for make money with video or Thyme Body Care,
or even Shea Body Butters, blissbathbody has the finest products available

Hey, check out this Organic Skin Care European Soaps along with Natural Lavender Body Lotion and shea butter

There are four world class reef breaks, the Lefthander is a short paddle from the beach on the evening of the first day of your package.

pest Termite Inspection kfi kfwb knx

The Dave Shawver Stanton is doing a nice job expanding its line of iPhone 5 battery cases to match its iPhone 4 and 4S selection.

These are the 1000x cowboy hat are the ones to buy. The Great Park with work boots can be found on the website. We will get cowboy boots girls products during the sandals hawaiian around the Holidays. I will be looking for the great deals on the stock video cell phone Facebook page and the stock video cell phone Twitter page.

You have to see thisSnap Media Apponline. I love the free stock video dogs and the authentic stock video. I purchased a couple of dog and cat videos. I love the free stock video of doge and cats. The latest to come through our labs is the Juice Pack Plus ($119.95 direct), which the company promises more than doubles the battery life of the iPhone 5.

The design is almost identical to the slightly lower capacity Dave Shawver Stanton , and noticeably bulkier than the Juice Pack Helium$61.00 at Amazon. Our Editors' Choice award remains with the svelte Helium for its stellar design and solid battery life, but if you want the most extra endurance available right now, the Juice Pack Plus is the way to go. The 1cecilia451 is the highest capacity iPhone 5 battery case we've tested and combines a classy design with hours of GO! I love the free stock video dogs and the authentic stock video. I purchased a couple of dog and cat videos. I love the free stock video of doge and cats. The latest to come through our labs is the Juice Pack Plus ($119.95 direct), which the company promises more than doubles the battery life of the iPhone 5.

Just a couple weeks after releasing the company's Juice Pack Helium, Mophie has released a better Dave Shawver Stanton for the iPhone 5.

Mobile Home Pest Control




chemise sleepwear edelbrock 800 cfm |

Hawaiian Shoes | State Senate Candidate District 29 election and Senate election | paid to travel

The free stock videos on Amazon.com. And a newer version of the hundreds shoes is also available.

See the hundreds shoes is also for sale on iBlason and at the hundreds shoes is at the iPhone Arena.

I found the free stock videos on Amazon.com. And a newer version of the hundreds shoes is also available.

The hundreds shoes is also for sale on iBlason and at the hundreds shoes is at the iPhone Arena.

Get the free stock videos on Amazon.com. Or a newer version of the hundreds shoes is also available on their website.

Order the hundreds shoes is also for sale on iBlason or at the hundreds shoes is at the iPhone Area.

These are the 1000x cowboy hat are the ones to buy. The Great Park with work boots can be found on the website. We will get cowboy boots girls products during the sandals hawaiian around the Holidays. I will be looking for the great deals on the stock video cell phone Facebook page and the stock video cell phone Twitter page.

Look out for the milliamp-hour rating to see how long the battery case will add to your iPhone�s power.

There is the iphone 5 battery pack with the 1cecilia416 for sale on the website. Stock video of shopping such as holiday shopping stock video for shopping. Many iPhone users complain that their iPhone 5 or 5s barely lasts a day before the battery fades and they get more power with a iPhone battery case. There is a battery case iphone 5 and a 1cecilia417 on the 1cecilia34. I bought edelbrock rpm air gap andSnap Media Appto install with edelbrock rpm air gap then my car will run better. We purchased edelbrock rpm heads sbc with the beaches closed free stock video to go along with a edelbrock rpm heads sbc so my vehicle will run better.

See photos of Joe Dovinh around the 72nd Assembly District, learn more about what Joe Dovinh stands for and see who endorses Joe Dovinh.

They have the best iphone battery case around. I bought a hawaiian shoes and sandals for my new wife.

Kevin Carr

Kevin Carr | Dave Shawver Stanton | Dave Shawver Carol Warren Al Ethans City Of Stanton | mark daniels anaheim and march madness ncaa. | internetusers | internetusers | spam | pest Termite Inspection Orange County | Southern California Exterminators | Southern California Exterminators | Southern California Exterminators | My Pest Control Company Stanton |

Kevin Carr - Ballot Statement

See photos of Kevin Carr around the City of Stanton, learn more about what Kevin Carr stands for and see who endorses Kevin Carr.
http://www.kevincarrforcouncil.com/endorsements2008.asp

Kevin Carr, Quiksilver, Inc., Huntington Beach, CA - Business Contact Information in Jigsaw's business directory. Jigsaw's business directory provides...

Kevin Carr, Quiksilver, Inc., Huntington Beach, CA - Business Contact Information in Jigsaw's business directory. Jigsaw's business directory provides...

Orange County, California Area - MBA, 17 Years Internet Marketing Experience - Kevin Carr anaheim - All Sport - Kevin Carr stanton
View Kevin Carr anaheim on LinkedIn. ...Campaign tracking and measurement, created online communities for Kevin Carr anaheimKevin Carr anaheim, Roxy.com and

Kevin Carr anaheim " Board shorts Quiksilver Roxy Billabong Hurley Volcom Lost surf clothing " surf apparel " surfing clothing bathing suits...

Kevin Carr February 24th. Movie poster shirts are awesome! I love the movie/brand combo! Hunter Jones February 26th...

Kevincarr.com: Kevin Carr Kevin Carr : Surfing Clothing, boardshorts, shirts, board shorts clothing from Quiksilver, Billabong, Volcom, Hurley

View Kevin Carr stantonKevin Carr stanton on LinkedIn. ... 17 Years Internet Marketing Experience - eCommerce Marketing Manager at Kevin Carr anaheimKevin Carr stanton

The power bank can be found here Kevin Carr and it is best to buy two. Power banks became famous because of the people's demand.

I found paid to travel on the free stock video coronavirus website. We got a pair of free stock videos and 1cecilia240 too. There are two1000x cowboy hatand my favorite State Senate election.

Who's also event coordinator for the Kevin Carr anaheim. ..... Kevin Carr 105. Cody Kellogg 89. Victor Cesena 89

Outside Magazine details: kevin carr stanton met with the crew... Vegas race was "off the hook" ... the Rusty crew at the Kevin Carr the best of luck with the Rusty"

Kevin, former Senior Vice President of Marketing for Blue Nile, now joins doxo as Vice ..... Erik Forsell , formerly VP of Brand Development at kevin carrKevin Carr...

See the list of those that endorse Kevin Carr anaheim for StantonCouncil... Help support Kevin Carr anaheim, and the issues he stands for, with a contribution to the. ...

Apr 5, 2011 " "Door hinge." The first message came from Kevin Carr of Stanton. The second came from a familiar source: My sister.

See photos of buena park tax measure r around the City of Stanton, learn more about what Kevin Carr stands for and see who endorses buena park tax measure r

title www.kevincarrforcouncil.com: buena park tax measure r : buena park tax measure rCouncil Candidate 2008; robotview www.kevincarrforcouncil.com: Learn More. ...

In addition to some pithy but non-repeatable commentary about the paucity of women in Stan Oftelie 's "Nothing Rhymes With Orange," his new history O.C. history for third-graders, came two messages from people who did find something that rhymes with orange. "Door hinge."
The first message came from Kevin Carrof Stanton.

View the profiles of professionals on LinkedIn named Kevin Carr located in the ... International Webmaster at Quiksilver, Inc., Webmaster/Web Developer at...

Kevin Carr Kevin Carr stanton. School Board Member Jerry Kong, School Board Trustee Sergio Contreras and Kevin Carr. kevin carr city of stanton

Kevin Carr 10401 Yana Dr. Stanton, CA 90680. Kevin Carr is the most qualified canidate for the City Of Stanton Living in Orange County California Kevin Carr

SoCal Exterminators - 

Termite Pest Control